Rating System & Permissions Guide
How record quality ratings, community voting, and editing permissions work on TAFOFILE
๐ป At a Glance
Rating System Overview
Every cemetery and people record on TAFOFILE is automatically assigned a completeness rating โ ๐ฅ Bronze, ๐ฅ Silver, or โญ Gold โ based on how thoroughly its fields have been filled in.
Ratings are calculated automatically every time a record is created or updated. You don’t need to do anything special โ just fill in as many fields as you can, and your rating improves!
Ratings serve two purposes: they help you track the quality of your own records, and they power the permissions system that determines who can edit which records. Higher-rated records are protected from casual edits, while lower-rated records are more open to community improvement.
Cemetery and people records use slightly different percentage thresholds to account for their different field structures:
Cemetery Record Thresholds
People Record Thresholds
Cemetery Record Scoring
Cemetery records are scored out of 104 total points. Four fields are mandatory (name, country, state/province, city) and contribute 16 points. All remaining points come from optional fields you fill in.
Required Fields (16 points)
| Field | Points | Validation |
|---|---|---|
| Cemetery Name | 4 | Non-empty; rejects placeholders like “Unknown”, “N/A”, “???” |
| Country | 4 | Non-empty selection from countries list |
| State / Province | 4 | Non-empty string |
| City | 4 | Non-empty string |
| Subtotal | 16 points | |
GPS Coordinates (10 points)
| Field | Points | Validation |
|---|---|---|
| Latitude + Longitude (pair) | 10 | Both must be present and non-zero |
Rich Content โ Descriptions & Photos (18 points)
| Field | Points | Validation |
|---|---|---|
| Historical Description | 8 | Minimum 100 characters |
| Photos (tiered) | 4 or 8 | 1โ2 photos = 4 pts; 3+ photos = 8 pts |
| Notes | 2 | Minimum 100 characters |
| Subtotal | 18 points max | |
Address, County & Location Detail (18 points)
| Field | Points | Validation |
|---|---|---|
| County | 6 | Non-empty string |
| Street Address | 6 | Non-empty string |
| Postal Code | 6 | Non-empty string |
| Subtotal | 18 points max | |
Web Presence (5 points)
| Field | Points | Validation |
|---|---|---|
| Website | 5 | Valid URL starting with http:// or https:// |
Research & Identification (25 points)
| Field | Points | Validation |
|---|---|---|
| Cemetery Type | 5 | Selection from dropdown (Municipal, Church, Family, etc.) |
| Denomination | 5 | Non-empty string |
| Established Year | 5 | Valid year between 1600 and current year |
| Alternate / Historical Names | 5 | Non-empty string |
| Status | 5 | Active, Inactive, Abandoned, Destroyed, or Relocated (not “Unknown”) |
| Subtotal | 25 points max | |
Visitor & Preservation (10 points)
| Field | Points | Validation |
|---|---|---|
| Estimated Burials | 2 | Integer greater than 0 |
| Condition | 2 | Excellent, Good, Fair, or Poor |
| Access Notes | 2 | Non-empty string |
| Hours of Operation | 2 | Non-empty string |
| Sources & Citations | 2 | Non-empty string |
| Subtotal | 10 points max | |
Contact Information (2 points)
| Field | Points | Validation |
|---|---|---|
| Phone | 1 | Non-empty string |
| 1 | Valid email address | |
| Subtotal | 2 points max | |
| Category | Max Points |
|---|---|
| Required Fields | 16 |
| GPS Coordinates | 10 |
| Rich Content | 18 |
| Address, County & Location | 18 |
| Web Presence | 5 |
| Research & Identification | 25 |
| Visitor & Preservation | 10 |
| Contact Information | 2 |
| Grand Total | 104 points |
People Record Scoring
People (memorial) records are scored out of 113 total points. The tier thresholds are โญ Gold โฅ 80%, ๐ฅ Silver โฅ 40%, and ๐ฅ Bronze below 40%.
Fields are weighted by how important they are to creating a well-documented memorial. Names and key dates carry the most weight, while supplementary details contribute smaller amounts. The same principle applies: fill in more fields = higher rating.
Essential Fields (10 points each)
| Field | Points | Validation |
|---|---|---|
| First Name | 10 | Non-empty; rejects placeholders like “Unknown”, “N/A”, “???” |
| Last Name | 10 | Non-empty; rejects placeholders like “Unknown”, “N/A”, “???” |
| Middle Name | 10 | Non-empty; rejects placeholders like “Unknown”, “N/A”, “???” |
| Maiden Name | 10 | Non-empty; rejects placeholders like “Unknown”, “N/A”, “???” |
| Birth Year | 10 | Non-empty |
| Death Year | 10 | Non-empty |
| Subtotal | 60 points | |
Date Components & Media (5 points each)
| Field | Points | Validation |
|---|---|---|
| Birth Month | 5 | Non-empty |
| Birth Day | 5 | Non-empty |
| Death Month | 5 | Non-empty |
| Death Day | 5 | Non-empty |
| Photo | 5 | Photo uploaded |
| GPS Coordinates | 5 | Both latitude and longitude must be present and non-zero |
| Subtotal | 30 points | |
Important Biographical Fields (3 points each)
| Field | Points | Validation |
|---|---|---|
| Occupation | 3 | Non-empty |
| Place of Birth | 3 | Non-empty |
| Place of Death | 3 | Non-empty |
| Cause of Death | 3 | Non-empty |
| Subtotal | 12 points | |
Burial Location Fields (2 points each)
| Field | Points | Validation |
|---|---|---|
| Section | 2 | Non-empty |
| Lot | 2 | Non-empty |
| Grave | 2 | Non-empty |
| Subtotal | 6 points | |
Additional Details (1 point each)
| Field | Points | Validation |
|---|---|---|
| Age at Death | 1 | Non-empty |
| Gender | 1 | Non-empty |
| Marital Status | 1 | Non-empty |
| Sources | 1 | Non-empty |
| Notes | 1 | Non-empty |
| Subtotal | 5 points | |
| Category | Max Points |
|---|---|
| Essential Fields (names & years) | 60 |
| Date Components & Media | 30 |
| Important Biographical | 12 |
| Burial Location | 6 |
| Additional Details | 5 |
| Grand Total | 113 points |
People ratings determine which community members can improve those records through the voting system, based on the permissions described below.
Who Can Edit & Delete Records
TAFOFILE uses a layered permissions system. Higher-quality records (Silver and Gold) are protected so that casual users can’t overwrite well-researched data. Here’s how it works, in order of priority:
People (Memorial) Records
โ๏ธ Who Can Edit
- โ The person who created the record
- โ Linked family members (mother, father, siblings, spouse, children)
- โ Premium subscribers (based on record rating โ see below)
- โ Active contributors (based on record rating โ see below)
๐๏ธ Who Can Delete
- โ The person who created the record
- โ Family members cannot delete
- โ Users flagged as “Restricted” cannot delete anything
- โ ๏ธ If others have contributed votes, suggestions, or edits, deletion requires admin approval
Cemetery Records
โ๏ธ Who Can Edit
- โ The user who created the cemetery
- โ Premium subscribers (based on cemetery rating โ see below)
- โ Active contributors (based on cemetery rating โ see below)
๐๏ธ Who Can Delete
- โ The user who created the cemetery
- โ Users flagged as “Restricted” cannot delete anything
- โ Cannot delete a cemetery that still has people records
- โ ๏ธ If others have contributed edits, deletion requires admin approval
Community Voting & Accuracy
Historical records aren’t always straightforward โ names can be misspelled on headstones, dates can conflict across sources, and new research can surface better information. That’s why TAFOFILE uses a community-driven editing system. Rather than overwriting someone else’s work, you suggest an edit and the community weighs in.
Users with access to a record can suggest a new value for key biographical fields โ or vote to support or challenge an existing suggestion from another contributor. You can also attach documentary evidence to strengthen any suggestion. The value with the strongest community support โ especially evidence verified by our admin team โ becomes the authoritative value on the record.
How It Works
Suggest an Edit
See a birth date that doesn’t match your research? Submit a suggested value for any eligible field. Your suggestion is added alongside the current value for the community to evaluate.
Support or Challenge
Review suggestions from other contributors and vote to support the ones you believe are accurate โ or challenge the ones you think are wrong. The more the community weighs in, the more reliable the result.
Attach Evidence
Strengthen any suggestion by attaching proof โ link to a source like Ancestry, FamilySearch, or a government archive, or attach a document from the TAFOFILE document library.
Best Value Wins
The system determines the most authoritative value based on admin-verified evidence first, then total evidence, then community support. The winning value is automatically reflected on the record.
Which Fields Can Be Edited?
The voting system covers the most important biographical fields on people records, including names (first, middle, last, maiden, nickname), key dates (birth, death, burial), personal details (gender, occupation, religion, marital status), locations (place of birth, place of death), burial specifics (section, lot, grave), and monument details (epitaph, stone material, stone type).
Earn Editing Permissions
Beyond your own records, there are two ways to unlock the ability to improve records created by others through the community voting system: active contribution (free and automatic) and premium membership (subscription).
Contributor Tiers (Free โ Earned Automatically)
TAFOFILE rewards active, high-quality contributors. The more well-documented records you create, the more you can help improve the entire database. Contributor tiers are calculated automatically โ no application needed. Your contributions speak for themselves.
People Record Contributor Tiers
| Tier | Requirement | Permission Earned |
|---|---|---|
| Tier 1 | Create 20+ Silver- or Gold-rated people records in the past 60 days | Edit ๐ฅ Bronze people records created by others |
| Tier 2 | Create 50+ Silver- or Gold-rated people records in the past 90 days | Edit ๐ฅ Bronze + ๐ฅ Silver people records created by others |
Cemetery Record Contributor Tiers
| Tier | Requirement (Past 30 Days) | Permission Earned |
|---|---|---|
| Tier 1 | Create 5+ Silver- or Gold-rated cemetery records | Edit ๐ฅ Bronze cemetery records created by others |
| Tier 2 | Create 10+ Silver- or Gold-rated cemetery records | Edit ๐ฅ Bronze + ๐ฅ Silver cemetery records created by others |
Quick Reference Summary
| User Type | Edit Own | Bronze (others) | Silver (others) | Gold (others) | Delete Own |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Free User | โ | โ | โ | โ | โ * |
| Linked Family | โ | Can edit & vote on any record they’re linked to as family | Own only * | ||
| Contributor Tier 1 | โ | โ | โ | โ | โ * |
| Contributor Tier 2 | โ | โ | โ | โ | โ * |
| ๐ฌ Research Pro | โ | โ | โ | โ | โ * |
| ๐ Legacy Plus+ | โ | โ | โ | โ | โ * |
Access to a record tier means you can suggest edits, support or challenge existing suggestions, and attach evidence. * Deletion of your own records is immediate if no one else has contributed to them. If other community members have added suggestions or edits, deletion requires admin approval to protect their contributions.
